It’s not even February yet but when I walked the aisles of my local market today, there was already an entire area devoted to all things Valentine’s Day. Instead of yelling “too soon!” and throwing a sea of conversation hearts on the floor, I am embracing the early celebration of v-day with Jane Austen. I know I’m asking for trouble with the title of this post, and I welcome it whole-heartedly. Please disagree with me in the comments.
- Sense and Sensibility
#Preach - Pride and Prejudice
At the time this sort of statement was revolutionary (at least for a woman to say out loud). Marrying was the only way for a woman to secure her future. If, like Austen, you did not marry, you were sure to be poor, obscure, and pitied. Choosing potential spinsterhood over a comfortable, but loveless, marriage makes Elizabeth Bennet a Georgian superhero. -
Northanger Abbey
I think we call agree that Isabella Thorpe is a mostly detestable person who uses Catherine to get to her brother James (whom Isabella thinks will inherit a lot of money). I can forgive her for some of this back-handedness, because lord knows being a poor, unmarried lady in the Regency must have been terrifying. Regardless, the above really rings true for me. -
Mansfield Park
Everytime I read this, I want to shout at the top of my lungs, “DAMMIT EDMUND, GROW A PAIR.” But I have to admit, the sentiment rings true. If someone loves you, they should treat you like you’re the sun and stars. Above all, the feeling should be mutual. -
Northanger Abbey
I’m partial to Henry Tilney because he’s very 3-dimensional and modern. Teasing Catherine Morland to within an each of her life, making fun of love, all the while falling for her. It is too sweet for words. -
Pride and Prejudice
Austen perfectly describes the sensation of falling in love: it sweeps you off your feet and creeps slowly up on you simultaneously. This line actually reminds me a lot of that now-famous quote from The Fault in Our Stars, “I fell in love the way you fall asleep: slowly and then all at once.” Perhaps John Green was paraphrasing Jane Austen all the while? -
Emma
Mr. Knightley says this to Emma when he finally professes his love and I go weak in the knees every time. (Jeremy Northam probably doesn’t hurt the situation either.) There’s something about a guy struggling to articulate his feelings, am I right? -
Sense and Sensibility
This is pretty much the definition of mutual affection. Sigh. -
Persuasion
BRB there’s something in my eye…
Alright, now that we’ve counted down Austen’s love quotes, get ready to see her life in a whole new light with Aerendgast: The Lost History of Jane Austen. I think a lot of readers are so intrigued by Austen because of her ability to write beautiful love stories without ever being in love herself. Aerendgast rewrites history and gives Jane Austen a story worthy of one of her novels. Coming out this February, stay tuned for details!
Okay, now let’s debate!
gailw
I love your choices, Rachel. And #1 always brings a tear to my eye. Boy, that lady sure could write!
Christina Boyd
I am in absolute agreement. Well done.
Deborah
I agree with your, especially with #1 as well as 2-9.
karen
#3 I might have put at #1, given my knowledge of the novel. To think that Knightley – who I see as smooth and elegant, fair and kind, sophisticated and articulate – to see him bumbling his words in his attempt to tell Emma how he feels about her – well, it’s an amazing combination of character and dialogue. I also love the Mansfield Park one – that book is tough to read, but there are some real gems in it.
Great list!
Kate
#8 “I am determined that only the deepest love will induce me into matrimon…” it is not Jane Austen’s quote! Elizabeth Bennet never said that, it was all Adrew Davies doing!
Debra
I agree with #1, and move #2 and #6 to the bottom because they imply that pleasing the man is more important than loving him, and that will be enough. Maybe it would have then, but my modern sensibilities, I guess, rebel. I agree with previous comment on #8, it is from the 1995 A&E/BBC production not the book.
Rachel Berman
Thanks for the feedback everyone! I can’t believe I quoted Andrew Davies! He is one of favorites when it comes to adaptations, so I will forgive myself this time…